The real diference between BIA and NIR

Jane becomes a member of a health club. As part of Jane's initial evaluation, the club's personal trainer measures her body composition using technology A and technology B.

TECHNOLOGY A

face1

BODY FAT PERCENTAGE = 25%

TECHNOLOGY B

face103

BODY FAT PERCENTAGE = 25%

Jane returns to her personal trainer after 45 days of hard work and commitment. She is excited to see her results!

TECHNOLOGY A

face2

BODY FAT PERCENTAGE = 28%

TECHNOLOGY B

face3

BODY FAT PERCENTAGE = 21%

Which technology would you prefer to use in your club?

Technology A is Bio Impedance. Technology B is Near infrared. Bio inpedance measures body water level using electrical conductivity. Based on the premise that lean body mass contains more water than fat mass, the more water you have in your body at the time of measurement, the greater the conductivity of the electrical current and the leaner you will test. A major concern with the technology is that a persons body water level fluctuates hourly based on the foods they eat, their activity, and other biological factors including a woman's menstruation, illness and disease.

The day of Jane's follow up test, she, like many people on the road to fitness, exercised for 30 minutes on the tread mill, drank a cup of coffee for breakfast, and had a drink of tea during lunch. Additionally, she was experiencing her menstrual cycle. Each of these factors, independently, will affect the accuracy of bio impedance measurement because they directly influence a persons hydration level. Jane is not only demotivated by her bio impedance results, she is upset.

Near infrared, opposite to bio impedance directly measures body fat, not body water. Jane's results in her follow up test accurately illustrate her achievement in attaining her fitness goals. Her motivation and excitement continue and spread throughout the health club and everyone she meets

Compare the ease and convenience of Futrex near-infrared technology verses other methods of body fat measurement

Mandatory pre-test requirements

Using Futrex's exclusive optical technology

Skinfold callipers

Underwater weighing

Using any bioimpedance technology

Need for fasting

No

No

Yes, minimum 2 hours

Yes, minimum 4-6 hours

Need for disrobing

No

Yes

Yes

Yes, stockings must be removed

Can measure following exercise

Yes

Yes

No

No, must wait minimum of 2 hours after exercise

Need for voiding

No

No

Yes, within 30 mins of test

Yes, within 30 mins of test

Measure any time

Yes

Yes

No

No, women cannot be measured prior to or during the menstrual period

Accuracy

Excellent

Moderate

Excellent

Excellent, if above criteria are followed

Repeatability

Excellent

Depends on Operator

Moderate

Excellent, if above criteria are followed

Possible risks

None

None

None

Yes, for implanted defibrillator; questionable during early pregnancy

© Intimex Holdings 2005

Intimex (Holdings) Limited. Reg office: Unit 5, Enterprise Park, Black Moor Road, Verwood, Dorset. BH31 6YS England.
Reg No 3354223

[Home] [Nasco Nutrition] [Contact us]